Pee Dee Valley

Book 12 of 13

The Open Hearing

The surveyor chose the meetinghouse for the hearing. Inside, every bench faced the same way. Nella got there early with her clay fish, which Sena had mended with a crosspiece wrapped around its tail, and turned the first bench so it faced the door. Adults spent a great deal of time putting benches back where they belonged. Nobody made her put this one back.

The surveyor sat beside an officer from downriver. He’d brought men of his own, and Pee could hear them passing a tin cup from one to another behind the shed. The officer had come to decide whether the firmer landing could be closed. He asked to be shown a public record establishing the claimant’s title. The surveyor gave him the sheet where Pee’s answer at the ford had been reduced to the word Empty.

Dee asked the officer to read the line twice. The second time she wrote it down the way he read it. Then she gave Pee room to say how the question had actually been asked and what he’d said. The surveyor let him finish. Afterward he asked whether Pee knew how much depended on remembering the exact words of an ordinary conversation in the middle of a day.

Rowan stood up and said she knew the conversation that came afterward. She told the room what the clerk had come to inventory and how he’d gone from room to room before anyone asked who lived in the house. Bran put the folded slip Dee had given back to him beside the survey sheet. In the first week of rationing he had signed it. Now he read the terms by which he would have acquired the shared landing. In front of everyone, he gave up the claim. The officer looked at his signature and asked why he had signed. Bran said he had wanted a lock he could use on his own door.

Dee read the names on the underside of the old landing board. A person who wished to speak could stand and say what they remembered of having built it. Wells, the clerk, told the officer where he’d been instructed to put the new chain. He spoke up again when the officer asked whether any of the stored corn had ever been sold. He said he had marked the baskets as stock. A woman whose household had contributed three baskets took her place on Nella’s bench and asked him to tell her the names on the labels.

Then Dee passed the copied accounts to the officer. She showed the coincidence of the debt marks, the vessel names and the names of the people to whom the watchmen were to report. Some names could be read out there. For others, she had written down the name of a person who could bring the officer to a witness for a private conversation, if the witness agreed. The surveyor asked for the names of the witnesses. Dee handed him the accounts again, open to the entries where his own seal appeared.

The officer said he would suspend the closure and hold the remaining grain while both banks appointed people to count it. He told Wells to take him to the salt landing at first light.

On the bench where the surveyor sat there was an open space. The ledger still lay there. A drop of water was creeping over its cracked cover toward the bottom.

Pee went out. He saw wet prints leading across the clearing toward the upper trail. The surveyor was already beyond the row of stones above the wash. He had returned to the tree from the wrong side.

“Take the other path,” Pee called.

The man stopped. From the hollow below him came the voice he’d used at the ford. It asked who owned the ground where his foot was about to fall. Pee heard the same man answer in a lower voice. People on both banks used it.

Pee called a second time. Wind moved through the tree and the voice was gone. The upper path was empty. There was no body to bring back to the hearing. There were families still waiting at the lower gate.

At first light Pee went with Wells and the officer. Dee took the ledger to Sena’s house. She set it next to the names Aster had taught her and waited for the women bringing breakfast to have a look at what they had won and what was still on the other side of the river.